Top 24 Hotels In Setauket, New York 11733

Enjoy a restful stay at Hilton Garden Inn Stony Brook on your journey to Setauket, where inviting rooms create a warm environment, with rates beginning at an accessible $271.99. Stay connected and entertained with Hilton Garden Inn's complimentary Wi-Fi and in-room streaming services for a variety of viewing options.

Guests staying at Hilton Garden Inn Stony Brook will love how close they are to downtown Setauket, where the city’s most iconic spots are always within easy reach. Make your Setauket travels both comfortable and cost-effective with inviting lodging—book today!

With elevated surroundings, Danfords Hotel&Marina near Setauket offers a refined environment, where tucked away accommodations start at an accessible rate of $229.99. Find enhanced luxury and comfort in rooms that offer additional space and upgraded amenities for a truly indulgent stay.

From Danfords Hotel&Marina, a short drive takes guests into downtown Setauket, where the city’s top attractions await exploration. Relax in Setauket with a hotel that takes care of every detail, so you don’t have to—lock in today!

With budget-friendly rooms from $209.99, Holiday Inn Express Stony Brook an IHG Hotel is an ideal choice for guests traveling to Setauket, creating a clean and inviting space for unwinding. Wake up to the Express Start™ Breakfast at Holiday Inn Express, a complimentary buffet featuring a wide variety of hot and cold options.

From Holiday Inn Express Stony Brook an IHG Hotel, a short drive brings guests into downtown Setauket, where the city’s most popular attractions are always within easy reach. Enhance your Setauket adventure with a hotel that makes every dollar count—secure now!

At Americas Best Value Inn Port Jefferson Station Long Island, travelers to Setauket can enjoy inviting accommodations with rooms starting at $155.00, creating a warm, welcoming space ideal for relaxation. Join the Value Club loyalty program at Americas Best Value Inn, earning discounts, rewards, and free stays.

From Americas Best Value Inn Port Jefferson Station Long Island, a brief drive brings guests into the vibrant downtown area of Setauket, where the city’s best attractions are within easy reach. Choose a reliable hotel for your Setauket adventure that won’t break the bank—book now!

Enjoy the welcoming atmosphere of Courtyard by Marriott Long Island MacArthur Airport as you explore Setauket, where restful rooms provide comfort, with rates beginning at an accessible $169.99. Relax with Courtyard's in-room entertainment systems, featuring the latest movies, streaming services, and music options.

Guests staying at Courtyard by Marriott Long Island MacArthur Airport can enjoy the calm of being slightly further out, with downtown Setauket still accessible for a day of sightseeing. Plan your perfect Setauket getaway with accommodations that make relaxation a priority—secure now!

At Homewood Suites by Hilton Ronkonkoma, guests visiting Setauket can find a balance of comfort and affordability, with inviting rooms available from a welcoming $192.99 per night. Relax in the separate living areas offered in every suite, providing ample space to unwind, work, or entertain.

Guests at Homewood Suites by Hilton Ronkonkoma can experience the best of both worlds: proximity to downtown Setauket and the tranquility of a more relaxed location. Enjoy the benefits of a Setauket hotel that combines elegance with savings—reserve now!

Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Holtsville is a welcoming choice for travelers to Setauket, where quality rooms offer a restorative retreat, with affordable nightly rates from $199.99. Prepare meals in fully stocked kitchens at Residence Inn, each suite equipped with modern appliances for your convenience.

Guests staying at Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Holtsville will appreciate the calm environment, with downtown Setauket still accessible by car for a day of city exploration. Relax and enjoy Setauket with a hotel that keeps your comfort front and center—reserve your room now!

Unwind at Jakes 58 Casino Hotel Adult Only near Setauket, where inviting rooms create a peaceful stay, with budget-friendly nightly rates starting from $188.99. Experience enhanced living spaces with thoughtful amenities that cater to both business efficiency and personal relaxation.

The calm setting of Jakes 58 Casino Hotel Adult Only provides guests a retreat, with the vibrancy of downtown Setauket still just a drive away for convenience. Experience Setauket with a hotel that makes luxury feel personal and inviting—book today!

Stay affordably at Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Hauppauge on your trip to Setauket, where safe accommodations create a warm atmosphere, with inviting rates beginning at $219.99. Host social gatherings in the outdoor spaces at Residence Inn, which are perfect for barbecues or casual get-togethers.

From Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Hauppauge, a convenient drive takes guests to downtown Setauket, where they can explore the city’s top spots before retreating to a peaceful stay. Take your Setauket experience to the next level with a hotel that delivers on all fronts—book today!

Guests bound for Setauket will find homely accommodations at Hampton Inn Long Island Brookhaven, with rooms starting at $137.99, creating a clean and welcoming space perfect for relaxation. Discover the charm of Hampton’s boutique-style properties, offering a unique and intimate hotel experience in select locations.

With a short drive into downtown Setauket, guests at Hampton Inn Long Island Brookhaven can explore the city’s highlights and return to the hotel’s tranquil atmosphere. Stay smart in Setauket with a hotel that offers comfort and peace of mind—secure now!

Explore a warm ambiance at Holiday Inn Long Island Islip Arpt East an IHG Hotel as you explore Setauket, where inviting accommodations provide relaxation, with rates starting at just $149.00. Bring along your pets to select Holiday Inn locations, where special amenities ensure they enjoy the stay as much as you do.

With a simple drive into downtown Setauket, guests at Holiday Inn Long Island Islip Arpt East an IHG Hotel can explore the city’s attractions while returning to the calm of their stay. Relax in Setauket with a hotel that takes your comfort seriously, without breaking the bank—lock in today!

At Hampton Inn Long Island / Islandia, travelers visiting Setauket can unwind in serene comfort with rooms beginning at $158.99, creating a warm and welcoming environment. Access cash when you need it with Hampton's convenient on-site ATMs, located within the hotel for easy withdrawal.

From Hampton Inn Long Island / Islandia, guests can enjoy a quick drive into downtown Setauket, where they can explore the city’s highlights and return to a peaceful stay. Discover the best value for your Setauket stay with a hotel that won’t disappoint—reserve now!

At Comfort Inn Medford Long Island, travelers bound for Setauket can enjoy alluring accommodations with rooms starting at $141.99, creating a clean and comfortable space perfect for rest. Take advantage of Comfort Inn's vending machines for quick snacks and drinks without leaving the hotel.

From Comfort Inn Medford Long Island, a brief drive brings guests into downtown Setauket, where they can explore the city’s highlights and return to a peaceful stay afterward. Rest assured your Setauket trip will be memorable and budget-friendly—secure now!

At Fairfield Inn by Marriott Medford Long Island, travelers to Setauket will find budget-friendly comfort with rooms beginning at $149.99, creating a clean and inviting environment. Relax in the contemporary design of Fairfield's guest bathrooms, featuring rainfall showers and upscale bath products.

Stay at Fairfield Inn by Marriott Medford Long Island to experience the perfect blend of quiet nights and quick trips into Setauket's lively streets. Plan your Setauket getaway with accommodations that make your stay seamless—reserve now!

For an inviting stay near Setauket, Rodeway Inn Macarthur Airport offers affordable comfort with rates from $129.00, creating a clean, calm space for unwinding and rest. Enjoy a comfortable retreat in rooms that offer the basic necessities for a relaxing and budget-conscious visit.

For a relaxing stay, Rodeway Inn Macarthur Airport offers quiet surroundings, with the added convenience of downtown Setauket being within easy reach. Plan your Setauket travels with comfort and affordability—book your room today!

Stay at Hilton Garden Inn Islip / MacArthur Airport for a relaxing visit to Setauket, where quality accommodations create a warm experience, with budget-friendly rates from $169.99 per night. Unwind in the Pavilion Lounge, a cozy spot at Hilton Garden Inn for enjoying a drink and catching up with friends or colleagues.

Rest easy at Hilton Garden Inn Islip / MacArthur Airport, where quiet surroundings create a peaceful stay and downtown Setauket remains within easy reach. Explore Setauket with a hotel that keeps you comfortable and stress-free—secure your accommodations now!

Guests traveling to Setauket will find delightful comfort at Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge an IHG Hotel, where rooms start at $246.39, providing a warm, welcoming environment perfect for relaxation. Enjoy the convenience of Holiday Inn Express's snack bar, offering a variety of treats and quick meals.

Relax in the quiet atmosphere at Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge an IHG Hotel, where peaceful surroundings offer a restful stay and downtown Setauket is nearby. Find your ideal blend of comfort and affordability for your Setauket stay—book today!

Encounter the charm of Clarion Hotel & Conference Center as you visit Setauket, with comfortable accommodations designed for relaxation, with rates beginning at an affordable $103.55. Relax in the serene ambiance of Clarion's spa facilities, offering massages, facials, and body treatments.

At Clarion Hotel & Conference Center, guests can enjoy the peaceful environment, while knowing downtown Setauket is a convenient drive away for city exploration. Discover a Setauket stay that combines elegance and affordability—book your hotel room today!

Guests traveling to Setauket will find 112 Motel a friendly, budget-conscious choice, with rooms beginning at $171.99, creating a welcoming environment ideal for relaxation. Stay in a room that ensures a comfortable travel experience, with basic amenities provided at an affordable price.

The serene atmosphere at 112 Motel provides a quiet retreat, with downtown Setauket just a drive away for exploration and excitement. Stay smart and comfortable on your Setauket visit without breaking the bank—book now!

For an affordable stay, La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Islip MacArthur Airport offers inviting rooms with rates beginning at $143.99, creating a clean, comfortable space ideal for relaxation. Appreciate La Quinta's dedication to cleanliness and safety, ensuring a worry-free and healthy stay for all guests.

A quiet retreat awaits at La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Islip MacArthur Airport, where guests can enjoy relaxation and still access downtown Setauket with ease. Make your Setauket adventure simple and enjoyable with inviting hotel options—lock in now!

At Commack Inn, travelers visiting Setauket can enjoy inviting accommodations with rooms from $181.99, creating a clean and welcoming environment ideal for rest. Experience a stay that delivers essential comforts, with rooms that are practical, clean, and well-suited for budget travelers.

The serene setting at Commack Inn makes for a peaceful stay, with downtown Setauket still close enough for guests to explore the city. Find the ideal base for your Setauket adventures with a hotel that adds value—lock in today!

Enjoy a warm environment at Radisson Hotel Hauppauge Long Island as you explore Setauket, where inviting accommodations offer quality and relaxation, with rates from $139.99. Discover Radisson's loyalty program, offering rewards and exclusive benefits to enhance your travels and encourage return visits.

Rest easy at Radisson Hotel Hauppauge Long Island, where guests can relax in serene surroundings with downtown Setauket within reach for sightseeing. Indulge in an exceptional Setauket escape where elegance meets relaxation—reserve now!

Experience a enveloping retreat at Residence Inn Long Island Islip / Courthouse Complex near Setauket, where comfortable rooms offer restful accommodations, with nightly rates beginning at a friendly $249.99. Enjoy a worry-free stay with Residence Inn's comprehensive safety protocols, including regular sanitization and health checks.

With a relaxing drive into downtown Setauket, guests at Residence Inn Long Island Islip / Courthouse Complex can explore the city’s best spots before retreating to the peaceful surroundings of their stay. Take your Setauket trip to the next level with thoughtfully designed, inviting lodging—reserve now!

Discover a homely escape at Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip / Courthouse Complex near Setauket, where inviting rooms provide relaxation and warmth, with budget-friendly rates from $279.99 per night. Step into Courtyard by Marriott, a haven where functionality meets relaxation, tailored specifically for today's traveler.

At Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip / Courthouse Complex, guests can relax in serene surroundings, with downtown Setauket still a convenient drive away for a day of adventure. Take the hassle out of your Setauket stay with a hotel that prioritizes your needs—book today!