Top 24 Hotels In Fire Island Pines, New York 11782

With budget-conscious rooms starting at $152.99, La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Islip MacArthur Airport provides inviting accommodations for guests traveling to Fire Island Pines, creating a clean, welcoming space. Experience the joy of travel with La Quinta's family-friendly accommodations, providing comfort and convenience for guests of all ages.

With a short drive into downtown Fire Island Pines, guests at La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Islip MacArthur Airport can explore the city’s highlights and return to the hotel’s serene environment. Find added comfort at a price that lets you enjoy more of Fire Island Pines—book now!

Find affordable comfort at Clarion Hotel & Conference Center near Fire Island Pines, where quiet accommodations create a peaceful retreat, with room rates starting at $103.55 per night. Experience the convenience of automated in-room dining at Clarion, where meals are delivered via a contactless system for privacy and efficiency.

Guests staying at Clarion Hotel & Conference Center will love the balance of easy city access and the tranquility of a more peaceful stay. Take your Fire Island Pines adventure to new heights with a hotel that keeps you well-rested and happy—lock in today!

Relax in the inviting comfort of Hilton Garden Inn Islip / MacArthur Airport as you travel to Fire Island Pines, where tranquil rooms await at an affordable starting rate of $168.99 per night. Appreciate the convenience of the 24-hour StayFit Gym at Hilton Garden Inn, where you can keep up with your fitness regime anytime.

With Fire Island Pines just a drive away, guests at Hilton Garden Inn Islip / MacArthur Airport can experience the city’s highlights while staying in a more peaceful, relaxed environment. Make every moment of your Fire Island Pines visit special with accommodations that impress—book today!

Guests traveling to Fire Island Pines can unwind at Rodeway Inn Macarthur Airport, where inviting rooms start at $129.00, creating a sheltered and welcoming environment perfect for relaxation. Enjoy a worry-free stay with rooms that provide standard amenities and a welcoming environment, perfect for a comfortable visit.

The drive into downtown Fire Island Pines from Rodeway Inn Macarthur Airport is convenient, offering guests easy access to the city’s top attractions without the noise. Stay relaxed and keep your wallet happy while visiting Fire Island Pines—lock in today!

Experience a restful retreat at Residence Inn Long Island Islip / Courthouse Complex when visiting Fire Island Pines, where appealing rooms provide warmth, with inviting rates starting from $249.99 per night. Experience the local culture with Residence Inn's staff recommendations for dining, shopping, and entertainment.

With Fire Island Pines a convenient drive away, guests staying at Residence Inn Long Island Islip / Courthouse Complex can explore the city’s highlights before returning to the calm and quiet of the hotel. Discover the ultimate in comfort and affordability in Fire Island Pines with a welcoming hotel—reserve now!

At Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip / Courthouse Complex, visitors to Fire Island Pines can enjoy a warm and restful stay, with comforting rooms providing a relaxing environment, starting at $279.99 per night. Indulge in Courtyard's pillow menu, offering a selection of pillow types to ensure your utmost comfort and a great night's sleep.

From Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip / Courthouse Complex, a convenient drive takes guests to downtown Fire Island Pines, where they can explore the city’s top spots before retreating to a peaceful stay. Unwind in Fire Island Pines with a hotel that makes relaxation feel effortless and affordable—reserve now!

Experience a warm stay at Homewood Suites by Hilton Ronkonkoma near Fire Island Pines, where quality accommodations offer comfort and relaxation, with inviting rates from $192.99. Appreciate the extra security of Homewood Suites' in-room safes, keeping your valuables protected during your stay.

Travelers seeking relaxation will appreciate Homewood Suites by Hilton Ronkonkoma, offering a quiet escape with downtown Fire Island Pines still accessible for sightseeing. Enjoy a memorable Fire Island Pines stay with a hotel that offers exceptional comfort and style—reserve now!

Guests visiting Fire Island Pines will enjoy the budget-friendly accommodations at 112 Motel, where gentle rooms start at $171.99, creating a warm and inviting space. Experience a welcoming stay in rooms that provide essential amenities and a comfortable setting, all at an economical price.

A quiet retreat awaits guests at 112 Motel, with downtown Fire Island Pines still within reach for a balanced stay of rest and adventure. Enjoy more of Fire Island Pines with a budget-friendly, comfortable hotel—book now!

Unwind at Courtyard by Marriott Long Island MacArthur Airport when traveling to Fire Island Pines, where plush rooms provide a comfortable retreat, with inviting rates starting at $169.99 per night. Indulge in Courtyard's gourmet market, featuring a selection of artisan snacks, local delicacies, and unique beverages.

The serene setting of Courtyard by Marriott Long Island MacArthur Airport offers a quiet retreat, while keeping guests close enough to downtown Fire Island Pines for easy access. Plan a Fire Island Pines adventure with a hotel that combines comfort with excellent rates—reserve now!

Relax in the inviting surroundings of Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Holtsville as you travel to Fire Island Pines, where quality rooms offer warmth and comfort, with rates beginning at $199.99. Discover Residence Inn, a top choice for travelers seeking extended stay hotels with full kitchens and comfortable living areas.

For a restful getaway, Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Holtsville offers calm surroundings with downtown Fire Island Pines still within reach for sightseeing and city exploration. Explore Fire Island Pines while enjoying a hotel that makes comfort and value a priority—secure now!

Unwind in the restful environment of Holiday Inn Long Island Islip Arpt East an IHG Hotel when visiting Fire Island Pines, where inviting rooms offer warmth, with nightly rates starting at an accessible $149.00. Take a breath of fresh air in Holiday Inn’s garden or patio spaces, ideal for relaxation or enjoying a quiet moment.

Guests staying at Holiday Inn Long Island Islip Arpt East an IHG Hotel will enjoy the calm setting, with the excitement of downtown Fire Island Pines still a smooth drive away. Maximize your Fire Island Pines visit with accommodations that offer style, comfort, and savings—book today!

Those visiting Fire Island Pines will appreciate the elevated comfort at Jakes 58 Casino Hotel Adult Only, where warm-hearted accommodations provide relaxation, with rates from $188.99 per night. Enjoy accommodations that provide a touch of opulence, with rooms that offer luxurious amenities and exceptional comfort.

Travelers will find a restful escape at Jakes 58 Casino Hotel Adult Only, where peace meets proximity to downtown Fire Island Pines for adventure. Step into a Fire Island Pines adventure where every moment is luxurious and enjoyable—book today!

For an affordable and restful stay, Hampton Inn Long Island Brookhaven offers delightful comfort with rates starting at $137.99, creating a warm and welcoming environment ideal for relaxation. Relax with a book or magazine from Hampton’s reading corner, featuring a selection of titles for guests to enjoy during their stay.

Guests at Hampton Inn Long Island Brookhaven can enjoy a serene escape, with downtown Fire Island Pines remaining accessible for city exploration. Rest and recharge in Fire Island Pines with accommodations that make every moment memorable—lock in today!

At Fairfield Inn by Marriott Medford Long Island, travelers bound for Fire Island Pines will find inviting comfort with rooms beginning at $149.99, creating a clean and welcoming space perfect for relaxation. Experience the warmth of Fairfield's guest service, where friendly staff are dedicated to making your stay as comfortable as possible.

Relax at Fairfield Inn by Marriott Medford Long Island, where guests can enjoy peaceful surroundings while keeping downtown Fire Island Pines within easy reach for exploration. Maximize your Fire Island Pines adventure with well-rounded, cost-effective accommodations—secure now!

At Comfort Inn Medford Long Island, travelers bound for Fire Island Pines can unwind in enchanting rooms with rates starting at $132.99, creating a warm and welcoming environment. Start your day right with Comfort Inn's complimentary hot breakfast, featuring eggs, waffles, fresh fruit, and more.

For those who want to enjoy both relaxation and city access, Comfort Inn Medford Long Island provides the perfect blend, with downtown Fire Island Pines just a drive away. Explore Fire Island Pines knowing your accommodations prioritize both comfort and savings—lock in today!

Guests visiting Fire Island Pines will appreciate the inviting comfort at Hampton Inn Long Island / Islandia, with budget-friendly rooms starting at $158.99, creating a clean, welcoming space. Commit to a greener stay with Hampton's sustainability initiatives, which focus on reducing waste and conserving energy.

For travelers wanting to escape the hustle of downtown Fire Island Pines, Hampton Inn Long Island / Islandia offers peaceful surroundings with convenient access to the city. Choose a hotel that brings comfort and affordability together in Fire Island Pines—book now!

Guests traveling to Fire Island Pines will find inviting accommodations at Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge an IHG Hotel, with rooms starting at $246.39, creating a clean and welcoming environment ideal for relaxation. Stay in the loop with Holiday Inn Express's IHG® Rewards Club, offering members exclusive benefits and rewards for their loyalty.

Relax in the peaceful environment of Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge an IHG Hotel, where guests can unwind while downtown Fire Island Pines is just a drive away. Stay worry-free in Fire Island Pines with a hotel that makes affordability feel luxurious—book today!

Discover a warm atmosphere at Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Hauppauge as you travel to Fire Island Pines, with restful accommodations that start at $219.99 per night, providing a relaxing retreat. Experience top-notch hospitality at Residence Inn, where friendly staff are always on hand to ensure your stay is seamless.

For a calm escape, Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Hauppauge offers a quiet retreat while keeping downtown Fire Island Pines within reach for sightseeing and adventure. Relax in Fire Island Pines at a hotel that combines elegance with budget-friendly rates—reserve now!

With a blend of charm and quality, Radisson Hotel Hauppauge Long Island near Fire Island Pines offers a delightful environment, where inviting rates start at an accessible $139.99. Stay inspired with Radisson's curated art and design books available in public spaces, encouraging exploration and creativity.

Guests at Radisson Hotel Hauppauge Long Island can appreciate the serenity of the hotel, while downtown Fire Island Pines remains easily reachable by car. Stay in Fire Island Pines with accommodations that make luxury feel attainable and effortless—lock in today!

Guests bound for Fire Island Pines will appreciate the intimate accommodations at Deer Park Motor Inn, where rooms start at $113.99, creating a welcoming atmosphere for unwinding. Enjoy a stay that balances comfort and affordability with rooms that offer upgraded amenities for a more satisfying visit.

A calm retreat awaits at Deer Park Motor Inn, where guests can rest and still reach downtown Fire Island Pines with ease. Enjoy your Fire Island Pines adventure with a hotel that’s all about great value—lock in today!

Relax in the warm ambiance of Home2 Suites by Hilton Long Island Brookhaven as you journey to Fire Island Pines, where quality rooms provide comfort and relaxation, with nightly rates starting at $185.99. Benefit from Home2 Suites' innovative color-coded guide to local dining, shopping, and attractions, helping you explore like a local.

For a calm escape, Home2 Suites by Hilton Long Island Brookhaven offers peaceful surroundings, while downtown Fire Island Pines is still close enough for city exploration. Find out how comfortable Fire Island Pines can be with a hotel that delivers exceptional service—lock in today!

At Hampton Inn Long Island / Commack, travelers to Fire Island Pines can unwind in calm comfort with rooms beginning at $207.99, creating a warm and inviting space ideal for relaxation. Appreciate the small comforts in Hampton’s rooms, such as ample charging ports and high-quality toiletries, enhancing your stay.

The serene environment at Hampton Inn Long Island / Commack provides a relaxing retreat, while downtown Fire Island Pines is easily reachable by car. Unlock the comfort you deserve on your Fire Island Pines trip with affordable lodging—reserve now!

Guests bound for Fire Island Pines will appreciate the easygoing accommodations at Super 8 by Wyndham Lindenhurst, with rates beginning at $167.99, creating a clean and welcoming space for relaxation. Relax with a wide range of in-room entertainment options at Super 8, ensuring there's never a dull moment during your stay.

Relax at Super 8 by Wyndham Lindenhurst, where peaceful surroundings create a restful stay, while downtown Fire Island Pines remains a quick drive away for sightseeing. Stay relaxed and within budget while exploring Fire Island Pines—lock in your hotel room now!

Guests visiting Fire Island Pines can enjoy affordable comfort at Holiday Inn Express Stony Brook an IHG Hotel, where pleasant rooms start at $214.99, creating a warm and inviting space ideal for unwinding. Experience the festive atmosphere during the holidays at Holiday Inn Express, with special decorations and seasonal offerings.

For travelers seeking both peace and proximity, Holiday Inn Express Stony Brook an IHG Hotel offers a calm retreat while keeping downtown Fire Island Pines nearby for adventure. Relax and enjoy Fire Island Pines knowing your hotel is both cozy and budget-conscious—lock in today!