The best deals on hotels when visiting Fireplace in New York.

From game day to getaway, save even more on every hotel stay.

Save up to 70% when booking as a group. Select 9+ rooms to get started.

Top 24 Hotels In Fireplace, New York 11937

The Roundtree Amagansett

273 Main Street Amagansett, NY

Relax in an opulent haven at The Roundtree Amagansett as you travel to Fireplace, where upscale accommodations guarantee an extraordinary experience, with rates starting from $695.99. Relax in rooms that provide a sanctuary of sophistication, with plush amenities and an atmosphere of discreet luxury.

From The Roundtree Amagansett, guests can easily reach downtown Fireplace by car, where the city’s top destinations are always within easy reach. Feel pampered in Fireplace with a hotel that creates unforgettable experiences—lock in today!

  Call (855) 235-6136 to book with an agent.
  4.8 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$695.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

The Reform Club

23 Windmill Ln Amagansett, NY

With rates starting at $1,092.99, The Reform Club provides budget-conscious accommodations for guests visiting Fireplace, creating a warm and inviting space for relaxation. Experience reliable comfort in well-appointed rooms that offer the basics for a pleasant and budget-friendly stay.

The Reform Club offers the perfect balance of proximity and peace, with downtown Fireplace just a brief drive from the hotel. Stay affordably and comfortably on your Fireplace getaway—reserve your room today!

  Call (855) 239-4019 to book with an agent.
  5.0 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$1,092.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Journey East Hampton

490 Pantigo Road East Hampton, NY

Travelers to Fireplace will find relaxation at Journey East Hampton, where luxurious accommodations provide comfort, with budget-friendly rates beginning at $360.07. Enjoy an elevated experience in rooms that offer a refined blend of luxury and innovative technology, designed for discerning guests.

Guests staying at Journey East Hampton will love how easy it is to drive into downtown Fireplace, explore the city’s top spots, and return to a peaceful retreat. Discover how delightful Fireplace can be with a hotel that makes luxury feel effortless—secure now!

  Call (855) 239-4019 to book with an agent.
  5.4 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$360.07

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

The Maidstone

207 Main Street East Hampton, NY

Those traveling to Fireplace will appreciate the comfort of The Maidstone, where quality rooms create a luxurious experience, with nightly rates starting from $593.75. Experience a stay where luxury meets innovation, with rooms equipped with the latest technology and plush, elegant furnishings.

With a brief drive into downtown Fireplace, guests at The Maidstone can enjoy the best of both worlds—city exploration and a quiet retreat afterward. Discover how Fireplace becomes unforgettable with a hotel that caters to your every wish—secure now!

  Call (855) 239-4019 to book with an agent.
  6.7 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$593.75

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

The Hermitage

2148 Montauk Highway Amagansett, NY

The Hermitage is an ideal choice near Fireplace, offering easygoing rooms and a touch of elegance, with nightly rates beginning at an inviting $230.26. Stay in rooms that provide a luxurious sanctuary, featuring elegant decor and a range of modern conveniences.

Guests staying at The Hermitage will enjoy the quiet atmosphere, while downtown Fireplace is still just a drive away for a day of sightseeing and adventure. Enjoy a Fireplace visit where every detail is designed for your ultimate comfort—reserve now!

  Call (855) 239-5277 to book with an agent.
  6.9 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$230.26

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Barons Cove

31 West Water Street Sag Harbor, NY

Step into elegance at Barons Cove on your journey to Fireplace, where comfy rooms create a peaceful retreat, with inviting nightly rates starting at $224.99. Enjoy a stay where luxury is seamlessly integrated with comfort, providing rooms that are both lavish and inviting.

At Barons Cove, guests can relax in a quiet setting, while downtown Fireplace remains within reach for easy access to the city’s top attractions. Make your Fireplace visit extraordinary with a hotel that knows how to pamper—book today!

  Call (855) 236-8982 to book with an agent.
  8.4 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$224.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Sag Harbor Inn

45 West Water Street Sag Harbor, NY

Step into relaxation at Sag Harbor Inn near Fireplace, where peaceful accommodations create a welcoming stay, with affordable rates starting at $229.99. Find a blend of comfort and luxury in rooms designed with your ultimate relaxation in mind, featuring superior amenities.

From Sag Harbor Inn, the drive into downtown Fireplace is straightforward, allowing guests to explore the city’s top destinations while returning to a peaceful setting afterward. Find the perfect balance of affordability and luxury in Fireplace—lock in your hotel today!

  Call (855) 233-7850 to book with an agent.
  8.4 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$229.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Gurneys Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

290 Old Montauk Highway Montauk, NY

Travelers exploring Fireplace will find Gurneys Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa a perfect choice, where refined rooms provide relaxation, with inviting rates from just $525.99. Experience a luxurious escape in rooms that feature elegant decor, advanced amenities, and a calm atmosphere.

Guests staying at Gurneys Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa will love how close they are to downtown Fireplace, while still enjoying the peaceful surroundings of the hotel. Unwind in Fireplace with accommodations that combine refinement and relaxation seamlessly—secure now!

  Call (855) 233-7850 to book with an agent.
  8.6 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$525.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Hero Beach Club

626 Montauk Hwy Montauk, NY

Enjoy an elegant retreat at Hero Beach Club as you journey to Fireplace, where inviting rooms offer relaxation, with affordable rates starting at $265.00. Stay in rooms that are a testament to the art of luxury living, offering a harmonious blend of comfort and extravagance.

A peaceful retreat awaits at Hero Beach Club, where the quiet surroundings provide rest and downtown Fireplace is still accessible. Take in the magic of Fireplace with a hotel that knows how to impress—secure now!

  Call (855) 235-0725 to book with an agent.
  10.5 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$265.00

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Topping Rose House

One Bridgehampton Sag Harbor Turnpike Bridgehampton, NY

Relax in the majestic ambiance of Topping Rose House as you visit Fireplace, where sophisticated rooms ensure a seamless experience, with rates starting at $412.00. Stay in rooms that redefine opulence, with lavish interiors and amenities that ensure an experience of unmatched luxury and relaxation.

Relax in the quiet environment of Topping Rose House, where guests can enjoy peaceful surroundings and downtown Fireplace remains nearby. Breathe in the beauty of Fireplace with accommodations that bring tranquility and style—reserve now!

  Call (855) 233-7850 to book with an agent.
  10.8 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$412.00

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

The Chequit

23 Grand Ave Shelter Island Heights, NY

The Chequit provides a warm retreat for travelers to Fireplace, where quality accommodations offer warmth and relaxation, with nightly rates starting at $316.99. Stay in rooms that offer a higher level of comfort and convenience, with amenities that ensure a pleasant visit.

Unwind at The Chequit, where peaceful surroundings offer a relaxing stay and downtown Fireplace remains nearby for city exploration. Stay smart and relaxed in Fireplace with a hotel that offers superior comfort—secure now!

  Call (855) 234-5074 to book with an agent.
  10.9 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$316.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Daunts Albatross Motel

44 South Elmwood Ave Montauk, NY

With budget-conscious rooms starting at $252.99, Daunts Albatross Motel provides affordable comfort for travelers bound for Fireplace, creating a reassuring and relaxing atmosphere. Relax in accommodations that offer a no-frills approach to travel, with essential comforts and a focus on economy.

A peaceful retreat awaits at Daunts Albatross Motel, where the quiet surroundings provide rest and downtown Fireplace is still accessible. Make the most of Fireplace with a comfortable, affordable hotel—book your room now!

  Call (855) 239-5277 to book with an agent.
  10.9 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$252.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Marram

21 Oceanview Terrace Montauk, NY

Enjoy a welcoming stay at Marram as you journey to Fireplace, where refined rooms create warmth and sophistication, with budget-friendly rates starting at $291.02. Relax in rooms that are crafted for luxury, with bespoke amenities and designs that cater to the needs of sophisticated travelers.

Travelers staying at Marram will appreciate the calm atmosphere, while downtown Fireplace is just a convenient drive away. Relax in Fireplace at a hotel that creates a sanctuary of style and comfort—lock in today!

  Call (855) 233-0132 to book with an agent.
  11.2 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$291.02

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

The Harbor Front Inn

209 Front St Greenport, NY

Find a charming retreat at The Harbor Front Inn as you explore Fireplace, where sophisticated accommodations offer comfort, with budget-friendly rates starting at $455.99. Relax in a setting that offers a higher standard of comfort and amenities, designed to make every stay memorable.

Escape the hustle of downtown Fireplace and unwind at The Harbor Front Inn, where the city remains within easy reach for a day of adventure. Enjoy a Fireplace escape that’s all about treating you to the finest amenities—reserve your room now!

  Call (855) 239-5277 to book with an agent.
  11.5 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$455.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Sound View Greenport

58775 County Rd. 48 Greenport, NY

Relax in the inviting surroundings of Sound View Greenport near Fireplace, where premium accommodations create a warm ambiance, with rates starting at an affordable $749.00. Find opulence in every corner, with rooms that showcase meticulous design and luxury amenities for an unparalleled stay.

Rest in the peaceful surroundings of Sound View Greenport, while knowing downtown Fireplace is just a convenient drive away for your city adventures. Get ready to explore Fireplace in elegance with a hotel that makes luxury accessible—lock in today!

  Call (855) 234-2997 to book with an agent.
  13.2 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$749.00

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

The Shoals Suites&Slips

61600 Main Rd Southold, NY

Relax in the charming ambiance of The Shoals Suites&Slips near Fireplace, where mellifluous rooms create a warm environment, with nightly rates beginning at $296.99. Experience a stay where luxury meets comfort, with rooms equipped with the finest amenities for a truly enjoyable visit.

Guests staying at The Shoals Suites&Slips will enjoy the tranquil surroundings, while downtown Fireplace remains easily accessible by car. Make every moment of your Fireplace trip memorable with a hotel that delivers elegance—secure now!

  Call (855) 239-4019 to book with an agent.
  13.2 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$296.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Southampton Inn

91 Hill Street Southampton, NY

Discover a relaxing retreat at Southampton Inn as you travel to Fireplace, where welcoming rooms offer restful accommodations, with nightly rates beginning at $205.00. Explore with confidence, knowing that Hampton by Hilton's locations are conveniently situated near local attractions and business centers.

For those looking to unwind, Southampton Inn offers a peaceful atmosphere, while downtown Fireplace remains just a drive away. Enjoy every aspect of your Fireplace trip with a hotel that delivers on quality—secure now!

  Call (855) 239-5277 to book with an agent.
  16.9 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$205.00

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

The Atlantic Hotel

1655 County Rd. 39 Southampton, NY

At The Atlantic Hotel, guests bound for Fireplace will find inviting accommodations with rooms from $152.99, creating a clean, comfortable environment for relaxation. Enjoy a stay that balances comfort and affordability with rooms that offer upgraded amenities for a more satisfying visit.

Guests staying at The Atlantic Hotel will appreciate the calm atmosphere, while downtown Fireplace is just a short drive away for exploration. Take advantage of a Fireplace hotel that makes your visit seamless and budget-friendly—reserve now!

  Call (855) 239-5277 to book with an agent.
  18.9 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$152.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

The Niantic Inn

345 Main Street Niantic, CT

Guests traveling to Fireplace will find cushy, budget-conscious comfort at The Niantic Inn, where rooms start at $179.99, creating a warm and inviting space for rest. Relax in accommodations that provide a comfortable environment, with everything you need for a worry-free visit.

At The Niantic Inn, guests can relax in serene surroundings, with the energy of downtown Fireplace still accessible by car for a day of exploration. Stay cozy and budget-conscious while exploring Fireplace—book your hotel now!

  Call (855) 235-0725 to book with an agent.
  19.3 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$179.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Saybrook Point Resort & Marina

2 Bridge St Old Saybrook, CT

Discover an elevated experience at Saybrook Point Resort & Marina near Fireplace, where relaxing rooms create a peaceful atmosphere, with affordable rates from $369.99. Experience a stay that combines luxury with practicality, featuring rooms equipped with top-tier amenities and elegant decor.

Rest in the serene surroundings of Saybrook Point Resort & Marina, knowing that downtown Fireplace is still within reach for easy city access. Get ready for a Fireplace adventure that combines luxury and affordability—lock in today!

  Call (855) 233-0132 to book with an agent.
  19.3 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$369.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

The Bentley Hotel Southampton

161 Hills Station Rd Southampton, NY

At The Bentley Hotel Southampton, travelers to Fireplace can enjoy inviting accommodations with rooms starting at $183.99, creating a warm, welcoming space ideal for relaxation. Find value in rooms that offer dependable comfort, making your stay both enjoyable and economical.

For a restful escape, The Bentley Hotel Southampton offers serene surroundings while keeping downtown Fireplace within reach for city exploration. Stay comfortably and save more on your Fireplace travels—lock in today!

  Call (855) 239-4019 to book with an agent.
  19.4 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$183.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Sea Haven Resort Motel

52 Longview Road Southampton, NY

Guests bound for Fireplace will find inviting accommodations at Sea Haven Resort Motel, with budget-friendly rooms starting at $117.99, creating a warm and welcoming environment. Stay in accommodations that simplify your travel plans, offering essential comforts and a focus on value and practicality.

For travelers looking for relaxation, Sea Haven Resort Motel provides quiet surroundings with downtown Fireplace just a short drive away. Plan a stress-free, budget-savvy stay for your Fireplace visit—book your room today!

  Call (855) 234-5074 to book with an agent.
  19.7 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$117.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Hilltop Express Inn

580 Poquonnock Road Groton, CT

With rates from $68.00, Hilltop Express Inn is a convenient option for travelers visiting Fireplace, providing welcoming accommodations in a welcoming environment. Find essential comforts in rooms that provide a clean and accommodating environment, with a focus on value and efficiency.

For a tranquil experience, Hilltop Express Inn offers spacious accommodations with Fireplace only a short journey away. Get ready for Fireplace with a hotel that brings comfort and value together—book today!

  Call (855) 234-2997 to book with an agent.
  21.0 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$68.00

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Pier Blue Inn Old Saybrook Essex

1430 Boston Post Rd Old Saybrook, CT

Guests traveling to Fireplace can unwind at Pier Blue Inn Old Saybrook Essex, where inviting rooms start at $133.99, creating a clean and comfortable environment perfect for relaxation. Rest easy in clean, comfortable rooms that offer standard amenities, ensuring a worry-free stay at a great price.

Surrounded by peace and quiet, Pier Blue Inn Old Saybrook Essex lets you relax while keeping the thrills of Fireplace within reach. Stay smart with affordable rates and cozy rooms on your Fireplace visit—book now!

  Call (855) 239-5277 to book with an agent.
  21.2 miles from Fireplace, NY 11937

Starting at

$133.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms