The best deals on hotels when visiting New Middletown in Ohio.

From game day to getaway, save even more on every hotel stay.

Save up to 70% when booking as a group. Select 9+ rooms to get started.

Top 24 Hotels In New Middletown, Ohio 44442

Davis Motel

10860 Market Street North Lima, OH

Guests traveling to New Middletown will enjoy the comfortable accommodations at Davis Motel, with rooms beginning at $78.99, creating a warm, inviting space perfect for rest. Find value in accommodations that offer the essentials for a comfortable stay, ensuring you get the most out of your trip.

Guests staying at Davis Motel can enjoy the quieter surroundings, with downtown New Middletown accessible by car for all their sightseeing needs. Stay comfortably and affordably for your New Middletown adventure—book your room today!

  Call (855) 233-7850 to book with an agent.
  5.2 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$78.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Holiday Inn Express & Suites North Lima an IHG Hotel

10111 Market St North Lima, OH

Guests traveling to New Middletown will find Holiday Inn Express & Suites North Lima an IHG Hotel a practical choice, with rooms beginning at $119.00, creating a clean and inviting environment ideal for relaxation. Appreciate the design of Holiday Inn Express's energy-efficient buildings, part of the brand's commitment to environmental stewardship.

The calm setting of Holiday Inn Express & Suites North Lima an IHG Hotel provides guests a retreat, with the vibrancy of downtown New Middletown still just a drive away for convenience. Experience New Middletown worry-free with a hotel that offers everything you need—book today!

  Call (855) 236-8982 to book with an agent.
  5.3 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$119.00

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

OYO Hotel North Lima OH Boardman

9955 Market St North Lima, OH

At OYO Hotel North Lima OH Boardman, travelers visiting New Middletown can enjoy restful accommodations with rooms from $57.86, creating a warm, inviting space perfect for relaxation. Experience thoughtful amenities and comfortable settings that provide a step up in value for travelers seeking more from their stay.

With downtown New Middletown still just a drive away, guests at OYO Hotel North Lima OH Boardman can explore the city’s best attractions while enjoying a more relaxed, quieter stay. Rest well in New Middletown with accommodations that make relaxation affordable—lock in today!

  Call (855) 236-8982 to book with an agent.
  5.3 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$57.86

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Best Western Plus Boardman Inn & Suites

7400 Tiffany S Poland, OH

For those visiting New Middletown, Best Western Plus Boardman Inn & Suites offers inviting, budget-friendly rooms with rates beginning at $92.99, creating a welcoming environment for relaxation. Stay refreshed with the in-room coffee and tea facilities at Best Western Plus, available for your convenience throughout your stay.

At Best Western Plus Boardman Inn & Suites, guests can unwind in a more spacious setting, with downtown New Middletown just a drive away for a day of city exploration. Take the guesswork out of New Middletown travel with a hotel that prioritizes your comfort—lock in today!

  Call (855) 233-7850 to book with an agent.
  5.3 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$92.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

FairBridge Inn Express North Lima

10076 Market St North Lima, OH

For an inviting stay near New Middletown, FairBridge Inn Express North Lima offers budget-friendly rooms with rates from $56.99, creating a clean and comfortable space ideal for rest. Relax in rooms designed for the budget-savvy traveler, offering essential amenities and comfortable surroundings.

With downtown New Middletown still within easy reach, guests at FairBridge Inn Express North Lima can balance city adventures with the peaceful surroundings of the hotel. Book a practical and comfortable stay for your New Middletown travels—secure today!

  Call (855) 233-0132 to book with an agent.
  5.3 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$56.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Hampton Inn Youngstown / Boardman

7395 Tiffany South Poland, OH

With budget-friendly rooms beginning at $106.99, Hampton Inn Youngstown / Boardman provides inviting comfort for travelers bound for New Middletown, creating a warm and welcoming space. Appreciate the small comforts in Hampton’s rooms, such as ample charging ports and high-quality toiletries, enhancing your stay.

With a convenient drive into downtown New Middletown, guests at Hampton Inn Youngstown / Boardman can enjoy the city’s top attractions while returning to the tranquility of the hotel. Enjoy your New Middletown stay with amenities that make your visit extra special—secure your room today!

  Call (855) 235-6136 to book with an agent.
  5.3 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$106.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Fairfield Inn & Suites Youngstown Boardman / Poland

7397 Tiffany S Poland, OH

With rooms starting at $119.99, Fairfield Inn & Suites Youngstown Boardman / Poland provides budget-conscious comfort for travelers visiting New Middletown, creating a reassuring, inviting space for relaxation. Trust in the consistent quality and service of Fairfield by Marriott, a reliable choice for travelers worldwide.

Guests staying at Fairfield Inn & Suites Youngstown Boardman / Poland will appreciate the quiet atmosphere, while downtown New Middletown remains accessible by car for easy city exploration. Get the rest and comfort you deserve while exploring New Middletown—secure your hotel room now!

  Call (855) 235-6136 to book with an agent.
  5.3 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$119.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Quality Inn & Suites North Lima Boardman

9988 Market St North Lima, OH

Guests bound for New Middletown will appreciate the delightful accommodations at Quality Inn & Suites North Lima Boardman, where rooms start at $78.99, creating a welcoming atmosphere for unwinding. Experience the freshness of Quality Inn's farm-to-table dining options, highlighting local ingredients and seasonal flavors.

From Quality Inn & Suites North Lima Boardman, the drive into downtown New Middletown offers guests easy access to the city’s top spots while keeping them away from the hustle. Enjoy the best of New Middletown with accommodations that enhance your travel experience—reserve now!

  Call (855) 239-5277 to book with an agent.
  5.3 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$78.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Residence Inn Youngstown Boardman / Poland

7396 Tiffany S Poland, OH

Relax in the welcoming atmosphere of Residence Inn Youngstown Boardman / Poland on your visit to New Middletown, where welcoming rooms provide comfort and quality, with room rates starting at $149.99 per night. Experience personalized service at Residence Inn, where staff go above and beyond to cater to your specific needs.

Residence Inn Youngstown Boardman / Poland offers the ideal setting for guests seeking peace and quiet, with downtown New Middletown only a short trip away for a day of exploring. Enjoy a New Middletown stay where comfort and convenience are never compromised—reserve now!

  Call (855) 235-6136 to book with an agent.
  5.3 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$149.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Baymont by Wyndham Boardman

7393 South Ave Boardman, OH

At Baymont by Wyndham Boardman, travelers bound for New Middletown can enjoy inviting accommodations with rooms starting at $69.99, creating a safe and welcoming atmosphere. Stay in control of your room environment with Baymont by Wyndham’s air conditioning and heating systems, ensuring your comfort year-round.

From Baymont by Wyndham Boardman, the drive to downtown New Middletown is straightforward, allowing guests to enjoy the city’s top attractions without the noise of staying in the center. Take a break in New Middletown with a hotel that understands the value of your time and money—book today!

  Call (855) 239-5277 to book with an agent.
  5.6 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$69.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Holiday Inn Youngstown South an IHG Hotel

7410 South Ave Boardman, OH

Explore inviting accommodations at Holiday Inn Youngstown South an IHG Hotel on your journey to New Middletown, where intimate-feeling rooms provide relaxation, with affordable rates beginning at $129.00. Enjoy the personalized service of Holiday Inn's concierge, ready to assist with reservations, tickets, and local recommendations.

The convenience of downtown New Middletown is just a drive away from Holiday Inn Youngstown South an IHG Hotel, making it easy for guests to experience the city’s top spots without the noise. Enjoy your New Middletown travels with a hotel that turns your stay into a true pleasure—book today!

  Call (855) 235-6136 to book with an agent.
  5.6 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$129.00

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Best Western Plus Dutch Haus Inn&Suites

150 East State Route 14 Columbiana, OH

For those headed to New Middletown, Best Western Plus Dutch Haus Inn&Suites offers budget-friendly comfort with rooms starting at $160.99, creating a clean, welcoming environment perfect for unwinding. Appreciate the artistic touches in the public spaces at Best Western Plus, featuring local art and creative designs.

Guests staying at Best Western Plus Dutch Haus Inn&Suites can appreciate the balance of being close to downtown New Middletown while enjoying the tranquility of staying outside the city’s busiest areas. Enjoy a seamless New Middletown experience with lodging that doesn’t compromise on comfort—book now!

  Call (855) 234-5074 to book with an agent.
  8.3 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$160.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Holiday Inn Express & Suites New Castle an IHG Hotel

2732 West State Street New Castle, PA

For an affordable and restful stay, Holiday Inn Express & Suites New Castle an IHG Hotel offers inviting accommodations with rates beginning at $159.00, creating a friendly atmosphere near New Middletown. Enjoy the simplicity and convenience of Holiday Inn Express's buffet dining, featuring a variety of options to suit all tastes.

From Holiday Inn Express & Suites New Castle an IHG Hotel, guests can easily access downtown New Middletown, making it simple to explore the city’s highlights and return to a serene retreat. Maximize your New Middletown adventure with well-rounded, cost-effective accommodations—secure now!

  Call (855) 235-6136 to book with an agent.
  9.0 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$159.00

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Hampton Inn & Suites New Castle

2608 West State St New Castle, PA

With affordable rooms starting at $112.99, Hampton Inn & Suites New Castle provides quiet accommodations for travelers bound for New Middletown, creating a clean, inviting space. Indulge in the comfort of Hampton’s plush seating areas in guest rooms, creating a cozy nook for reading or relaxing.

With downtown New Middletown a drive from Hampton Inn & Suites New Castle, guests can explore the city’s top spots while enjoying a more relaxed stay away from the bustle. Unwind in New Middletown with lodging that ensures you’re rested and refreshed—lock in today!

  Call (855) 239-4019 to book with an agent.
  9.1 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$112.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Towneplace Suites by Marriott Canfield

4100 Westford Pl Canfield, OH

Guests visiting New Middletown will appreciate the affordable comfort at Towneplace Suites by Marriott Canfield, with harmonious rooms starting at $159.99, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. Benefit from the convenience of TownePlace Suites' 24-hour In a Pinch® market, offering snacks, drinks, and essentials anytime.

Guests at Towneplace Suites by Marriott Canfield will love the quiet setting of the hotel, with downtown New Middletown still a short drive away for easy city exploration. Plan your New Middletown adventure with inviting, affordable lodging—secure your room now!

  Call (855) 239-5277 to book with an agent.
  9.5 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$159.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Courtyard by Marriott Youngstown Canfield

4173 Westford Place Canfield, OH

Relax in the cushy surroundings of Courtyard by Marriott Youngstown Canfield as you travel to New Middletown, where quality accommodations provide comfort, with nightly rates from $149.99. Take advantage of Courtyard's efficient dry cleaning service, ensuring your clothes are clean and ready when you need them, even on short notice.

At Courtyard by Marriott Youngstown Canfield, guests can appreciate the relaxing environment, while downtown New Middletown remains a short drive away for all their city adventures. Plan an unforgettable New Middletown trip with accommodations that make every moment enjoyable—reserve now!

  Call (855) 239-5277 to book with an agent.
  9.5 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$149.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Hampton Inn & Suites Youngstown Canfield

6690 Ironwood Blvd Canfield, OH

With rates beginning at $135.99, Hampton Inn & Suites Youngstown Canfield provides budget-friendly comfort for travelers bound for New Middletown, creating a clean, inviting space. Indulge in the added luxury of upgraded bedding options in select Hampton guest rooms, featuring premium linens and pillows.

At Hampton Inn & Suites Youngstown Canfield, guests can appreciate the balance of city convenience and a more peaceful, spacious stay, with downtown New Middletown still within reach. Relax and enjoy New Middletown knowing your hotel is both cozy and budget-conscious—lock in today!

  Call (855) 233-7850 to book with an agent.
  10.0 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$135.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

DoubleTree by Hilton Youngstown Downtown

44 East Federal St Youngstown, OH

Those visiting New Middletown will be enchanted by DoubleTree by Hilton Youngstown Downtown, where sophisticated accommodations set a new standard for luxury, with nightly rates beginning at $305.99. Work seamlessly with DoubleTree by Hilton's business amenities, ensuring productivity remains uninterrupted.

Enjoy the quiet surroundings at DoubleTree by Hilton Youngstown Downtown, where downtown New Middletown remains accessible by car for a day of sightseeing and adventure. Step into a New Middletown hotel that knows how to make your visit truly memorable—secure your room now!

  Call (855) 236-8982 to book with an agent.
  10.4 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$305.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Quality Inn & Suites New Castle

1740 NE Butler Rd New Castle, PA

With rooms starting at $76.99, Quality Inn & Suites New Castle provides budget-conscious accommodations for travelers visiting New Middletown, creating a clean and restorative space. Step into the inviting ambiance of Quality Inn, where each guest is guaranteed comfort and convenience at an unbeatable value.

A restful retreat awaits at Quality Inn & Suites New Castle, where quiet surroundings provide relaxation and downtown New Middletown remains close by. Uncover the perfect balance of comfort and affordability in New Middletown—reserve today!

  Call (855) 234-5074 to book with an agent.
  13.0 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$76.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Westgate Manor Motel by OYO Youngstown Austintown

4493 Mahoning Avenue Austintown, OH

For a cushy stay near New Middletown, Westgate Manor Motel by OYO Youngstown Austintown offers inviting accommodations with rooms beginning at $64.99, creating a warm and welcoming environment ideal for rest. Enjoy the convenience of rooms equipped with necessary comforts, providing a solid foundation for a budget-friendly journey.

At Westgate Manor Motel by OYO Youngstown Austintown, guests can enjoy a quiet escape, knowing downtown New Middletown is still within driving distance for a day of exploration. Make your New Middletown adventure comfortable and easy on the wallet—book today!

  Call (855) 239-5277 to book with an agent.
  13.2 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$64.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Super 8 by Wyndham New Castle

1699 NE Butler Rd New Castle, PA

Guests traveling to New Middletown will appreciate the affordable comfort at Super 8 by Wyndham New Castle, where rooms begin at $82.00, creating a warm and inviting space for relaxation. Take advantage of Super 8's locations, strategically situated near highways, restaurants, and attractions for easy travel planning.

A peaceful retreat awaits at Super 8 by Wyndham New Castle, while the excitement of downtown New Middletown is just a convenient drive away for exploration. Enjoy enhanced comfort at a great price for your New Middletown travels—secure now!

  Call (855) 239-5277 to book with an agent.
  13.2 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$82.00

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

ELDORADO MOTEL

2618 NE Butler Rd New Castle, PA

With rooms starting at $91.99, ELDORADO MOTEL is an affordable choice for guests visiting New Middletown, creating a clean, welcoming space perfect for a peaceful stay. Enjoy a stay that simplifies your travel needs, with rooms equipped with essential amenities for a stress-free experience.

Guests staying at ELDORADO MOTEL will appreciate the calm atmosphere, while downtown New Middletown is just a short drive away for exploration. Enjoy New Middletown adventures with a cozy, budget-friendly stay—secure your room today!

  Call (855) 236-8982 to book with an agent.
  14.0 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$91.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Days Inn & Suites by Wyndham Youngstown / Girard Ohio

1615 East Liberty St Girard, OH

With affordable rooms starting at $58.99, Days Inn & Suites by Wyndham Youngstown / Girard Ohio provides budget-friendly comfort for travelers to New Middletown, creating a welcoming environment for rest and ease. Trust in Days Inn for a pleasant and straightforward lodging experience, ensuring your travel needs are met with ease.

Guests at Days Inn & Suites by Wyndham Youngstown / Girard Ohio will enjoy a calm atmosphere, while downtown New Middletown is just a convenient drive away for a day of adventure. Plan your New Middletown adventure with ease and affordability—secure your stay today!

  Call (855) 234-2997 to book with an agent.
  14.1 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$58.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms

Baymont by Wyndham Youngstown

4055 Belmont Ave Youngstown, OH

At Baymont by Wyndham Youngstown, travelers to New Middletown can enjoy inviting accommodations with rates starting at $52.99, providing a welcoming, comfortable environment. Stay energized with Baymont by Wyndham’s breakfast options, which include healthy and hearty choices to start your day right.

A peaceful retreat awaits guests at Baymont by Wyndham Youngstown, with downtown New Middletown still within reach for city exploration and activities. Enjoy your New Middletown adventure with a hotel that pairs quality and affordability—lock in today!

  Call (855) 234-7135 to book with an agent.
  14.2 miles from New Middletown, OH 44442

Starting at

$52.99

per night

Read Reviews View Amenities View All Rooms